Tuesday
Aug082006
399.1 - Blackboard Patents? Learning Museum, Dorothy Wins

Learning TRENDS by Elliott Masie - August 8, 2006.
#399.1 - Updates on Learning, Business & Technology.
52,559 Readers - http://www.masie.com - The MASIE Center.
Learning 2006 - Nov 5-8 - Orlando - www.learning2006.com.
1. Blackboard Patents for e-Learning?
2. Learning Technology Museum Launching.
3. Dorothy's Destiny Wins!
(Note: We are working on a very exciting 400th edition of TRENDS. But, it make take a week or so more. Hence, we'll use 399.1 and 399.2 to save the 400th for our special edition - Elliott)
1. Blackboard Patents for e-Learning? The Patents for e-Learning conversations and legal fights continue. Recently, Blackboard, an LMS provider with roots in the academic space, was awarded a patent covering a number of processes and technologies related to e-Learning. They rapidly filed suit against Desire2Learn, claiming infringement of their patent.
The "blogsphere" is loaded with analysis and concern about the impact of these e-Learning patents. Here are a few resources that you might want to
review:
Blackboard's View: http://www.blackboard.com/patent
Analysis from Other Sources:
http://www.technorati.com/search/blackboard%20patent
http://mfeldstein.com/images/uploads/Blackboard_Patent_Claims.pdf
The MASIE Center is concerned about the patent award process for e-Learning and we have testified as unpaid witnesses in a recent suit, to counter the claims. We believe that there is substantial "prior art" in this arena, though the strategy is often to drive up the cost of litigation until the case is settled.
While patents for legitimate inventions are a key aspect of our society, I am not convinced that these recent e-Learning patents were awarded accurately and am concerned that the patents may have a disruptive effect on both LMS procurement and innovation in our field.
We will be hosting a special set of sessions on Patents & Learning at Learning 2006 to be held in Orlando, Florida on November 5 to 8th.
http://www.learning2006.com/blog/
2. Learning Technology Museum Launching: I am pleased to announce that The MASIE Center is creating a new Learning Technology Museum collection. We want to gather learning technology that is decades old, as well as emerging models of new learning technology. The first display will be at Learning 2006. I will be working with Kevin Oakes, one of the pioneers in our field, to assemble this display, which will be based at The MASIE Center and travel to key events around the country. If you have historical items to add to the Learning Technology Museum, please send me a note to emasie@masie.com
3. Dorothy's Destiny Wins! Our horse, Dorothy's Destiny, won her first race last Thursday at Saratoga! She was named after my mom, who had equal spunk and died at age 90 a few years ago. Dorothy's Destiny led from "wire to wire" and won her maiden race at the racetrack of champions. If you would like to see her race picture, go to http://www.masie.com/dorothy/
MASIE Center Events & Services:
* Learning 2006 - Orlando, Florida - Nov 5 to 8th.
* Membership in the Learning CONSORTIUM.
Info at: http://www.masie.com
#399.1 - Updates on Learning, Business & Technology.
52,559 Readers - http://www.masie.com - The MASIE Center.
Learning 2006 - Nov 5-8 - Orlando - www.learning2006.com.
1. Blackboard Patents for e-Learning?
2. Learning Technology Museum Launching.
3. Dorothy's Destiny Wins!
(Note: We are working on a very exciting 400th edition of TRENDS. But, it make take a week or so more. Hence, we'll use 399.1 and 399.2 to save the 400th for our special edition - Elliott)
1. Blackboard Patents for e-Learning? The Patents for e-Learning conversations and legal fights continue. Recently, Blackboard, an LMS provider with roots in the academic space, was awarded a patent covering a number of processes and technologies related to e-Learning. They rapidly filed suit against Desire2Learn, claiming infringement of their patent.
The "blogsphere" is loaded with analysis and concern about the impact of these e-Learning patents. Here are a few resources that you might want to
review:
Blackboard's View: http://www.blackboard.com/patent
Analysis from Other Sources:
http://www.technorati.com/search/blackboard%20patent
http://mfeldstein.com/images/uploads/Blackboard_Patent_Claims.pdf
The MASIE Center is concerned about the patent award process for e-Learning and we have testified as unpaid witnesses in a recent suit, to counter the claims. We believe that there is substantial "prior art" in this arena, though the strategy is often to drive up the cost of litigation until the case is settled.
While patents for legitimate inventions are a key aspect of our society, I am not convinced that these recent e-Learning patents were awarded accurately and am concerned that the patents may have a disruptive effect on both LMS procurement and innovation in our field.
We will be hosting a special set of sessions on Patents & Learning at Learning 2006 to be held in Orlando, Florida on November 5 to 8th.
http://www.learning2006.com/blog/
2. Learning Technology Museum Launching: I am pleased to announce that The MASIE Center is creating a new Learning Technology Museum collection. We want to gather learning technology that is decades old, as well as emerging models of new learning technology. The first display will be at Learning 2006. I will be working with Kevin Oakes, one of the pioneers in our field, to assemble this display, which will be based at The MASIE Center and travel to key events around the country. If you have historical items to add to the Learning Technology Museum, please send me a note to emasie@masie.com
3. Dorothy's Destiny Wins! Our horse, Dorothy's Destiny, won her first race last Thursday at Saratoga! She was named after my mom, who had equal spunk and died at age 90 a few years ago. Dorothy's Destiny led from "wire to wire" and won her maiden race at the racetrack of champions. If you would like to see her race picture, go to http://www.masie.com/dorothy/
MASIE Center Events & Services:
* Learning 2006 - Orlando, Florida - Nov 5 to 8th.
* Membership in the Learning CONSORTIUM.
Info at: http://www.masie.com